|
The ear
cropping ban has resurfaced
in the California Legislature.
Introduced by Assemblyman
Koretz, Assembly
Bill 418 not only
prohibits this animal
husbandry practice,
it places civil penalties
on anyone who arranges
to have the procedure
done on any dog in the
state and may even affect
California residents
who take their dogs
out of state for the
procedure. Maximum fine
for a violation is $10,000
to be paid to the jurisdiction
in which the violation
occurs.
In an
attempt to blunt opposition,
Koretz has specified
that dogs with cropped
ears can compete in
dog events in the state,
has not banned ownership
or sale of dogs with
cropped ears, and allows
for cropping for therapeutic
reasons. However, prevention
of ear infections is
not considered a therapeutic
reason.
NAIA Trust
opposes AB 418 because
it ...
-
creates
an enforcement climate
in which activists
could harass veterinarians
and dog owners and
breeders;
-
represents
an unwarranted intrusion
in the relationship
between dog owners
and their veterinarians;
-
is
impossible to enforce
without interfering
in the practice
of veterinary medicine;
-
could make dog owners
liable even if the
surgery is done
in another state;
-
carries
a large and unfair
penalty that could
drive ear cropping
underground; and
-
establishes
a precedent that
replaces the professional
judgment of veterinarians
with laws based
on the beliefs of
special interest
advocates.
NAIA
Trust agrees with the
words of Dr. Peter Weinstein,
past president of the
California Veterinary
Medical Association:
“The practice
of veterinary medicine
should be left to veterinarians
with the best interest
of the patient and animal
owners in mind.”
Dr. Weinstein’s
comments were made to
the West Hollywood City
Council on February
7, 2005, and can be
found here.
The NAIA
Trust sample opposition
letter can be found
here.
Dog owners
helped defeat a cropping
ban last year and can
do so again by making
our opposition known.
Since the bill has not
yet been assigned to
a legislative committee
for hearings, we suggest
that California residents
contact their own assembly
members and senators
immediately and that
those who attend dog
events in the state
write to the representatives
from the jurisdictions
where the events are
held. Go here
and enter the zip code
of the hotel you are
using or the show site
itself to find the names
of representatives from
that area.
California State Assembly Members
Assemblymember.aghazarian@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.arambula@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Baca@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Bass@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.benoit@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.berg@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.bermudez@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.blakeslee@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Bogh@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.ron.calderon@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Canciamilla@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Chan@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Chavez@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.chu@asm.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Cogdill@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Cohn@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Coto@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Daucher@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Delatorre@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.devore@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.dymally@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.emmerson@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.evans@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Frommer@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblywoman.garcia@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Goldberg@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Gordon@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.hancock@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Harman@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.haynes@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Jerome.Horton@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Shirley.Horton@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Houston@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Huff@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.jones@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.jkarnette@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.keene@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.klehs@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Koretz@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.lamalfa@assembly.ca.gov
Assemblymember.Lasuer@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.laird@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.leno@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Leslie@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.levine@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblywoman.lieber@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Liu@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Matthews@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.maze@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.mccarthy@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.montanez@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Mountjoy@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.mullin@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.nakanishi@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.nation@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.nava@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.McLeod@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.niello@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.nunez@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Oropeza@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Parra@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Pavley@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.plescia@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Richman@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.ridley-thomas@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblywoman.Runner@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblywoman.Ruskin@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblywoman.Saldana@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Salinas@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.spitzer@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.strickland@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.torrico@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.tran@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.umberg@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Vargas@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.villines@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.walters@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.wolk@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.Wyland@assembly.ca.gov,
Assemblymember.yee@assembly.ca.gov
California State Senators
senator.aanestad@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.ackerman@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.alcaron@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Alquist@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.ashburn@sen.ca.gov,
Senator Jim.Battin@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.bowen@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.campbell@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Cedillo@SEN.CA.GOV,
Senator.chesbro@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.cox@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.denham@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Ducheny@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.dunn@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Dutton@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.escutia@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Figueroa@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Florez@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.hollingsworth@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.karnette@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Kehoe@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Kuehl@SEN.CA.GOV,
Senator.Lowenthal@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Machado@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Maldonado@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Margett@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.McClintock@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Migden@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Morrow@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Murray@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Ortiz@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Perata@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Poochigian@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Romero@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Runner@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Scott@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Simitian@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Soto@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Speier@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Torlakson@sen.ca.gov,
Senator.Vincent@sen.ca.gov
|